The Lamanite Truth Project – Part One

     The Lamanite Truth Project is a call to address the current teachings of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints towards Native Americans. This project is an effort to cease all speculation about who the Lamanite people are, stop religious racism, and make a plea to remove the term “American Indians” from the Introduction of the Book of Mormon. As part of this effort the Lamanite Truth Project will focus on missionary work within Mormonism.

Part One – Speculation of Lamanite Identity

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints has identified “American Indians” as Lamanites since its founding in 1830. The Introduction to the Book of Mormon states, “After thousands of years, all were destroyed except the Lamanites, and they are among the ancestors of the American Indians.” The Book of Mormon is still being taught to Native Americans and Indigenous peoples as being an accurate historical record of their direct ancestors. Archaeology, DNA, and Indigenous oral history all disprove this claim.

The terms: American Indian, Indian, Lamanite, and Children of Lehi are all labels the church has used interchangeably throughout its history to identify Native Americans. Since the Book of Mormon uses the term “American Indian”  this will appear often throughout the Lamanite Truth Project, but only to reflect the Mormon terminology. Please be sensitive to the Native American community as they have often been wrongly labeled.

Listed below are just some of the issues surrounding the term Lamanite when used to identify “American Indians”:

1- Native Americans have a rich and beautiful heritage. Telling Native Americans that they do not know their own history or ancestry is offensive. The act of replacing their heritage is a form of colonization and cultural genocide. This should never have happened to begin with, but with the knowledge we now have it definitely should not still be happening within Mormonism.

2- Native American cultural and spiritual traditions are considered remnants of evil within the Lamanite story found in the Book of Mormon. This destroys the beauty and spirituality of real living people. Native Americans should feel no shame over their cultural traditions, nor shame about their ancestors. They have been forced to choose between culture and the church, for choosing both is not welcomed in Mormonism.

3- Native American evil ancestry – The Book of Mormon teaches that American Indian ancestors were so evil that God cursed them by completely withdrawing His spirit from them. This is the reason Mormons give as to why Native Americans had no religion when America was colonized. This shows complete disregard for religious freedom, and total ignorance about Native American spirituality. The level of evil required for God to completely withdraw His spirit from an entire people has been put upon American Indians in the pages of the Book of Mormon.

4- Native American ancestors were cursed with dark skin in the Book of Mormon. This dark skin curse was a physical sign of the greater curse, God removing His spirit from them. Darkened skin, as taught in the Book of Mormon, is a sign to more righteous people. God did this so the righteous might easily identify the unrighteous. God’s purpose for this physical sign of dark skin was to keep the righteous people from mixing (marrying) with the unrighteous people. Teaching living Native American people that this is the reason for their skin pigmentation, that it is a punishment from God, is deeply offensive.

5- Native Americans pass on the sign of the curse, darkened skin, to their children. Another generation of Native American descendants raised with toxic religious racism. Babies… Native Americans should not be told that the pigmentation of their beautiful new babies are the result of ancestral curses. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints claims it never apologizes. In this instance it needs to. Speculation over “Lamanite” identity needs to cease.

6- Native Americans that join Mormonism are promised that the curse that God removed His spirit from them will be lifted if they join the Mormon church. However, any of their family that does not join The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints will still carry the curse. This deeply hurts and affects family relationships. Cultural shaming pushed into and between family members.

7- Native Americans have been taught that their skin will lighten in pigment as they embrace the gospel within The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. This is no longer a much talked about aspect of Lamanite identity, but it still exists. Living Native Americans were taught this and raised with this belief.

8- Native American ancestors turned away from God in the Lamanite story, thereby causing the Indigenous genocide and colonization of America. The Book of Mormon states that God punishes them with with the bloodshed of their people and the taking of their land. God brings people from other nations and gives American Indian lands to the new more righteous people. The Book of Mormon states: “Yea, he will bring other nations unto them, and he will give unto them power, and he will take away from them the lands of their possessions, and he will cause them to be scattered and smitten. Yea, as one generation passeth to another there shall be bloodsheds…” (2 Nephi: Chap 1)  This is a massively disrespectful teaching to the surviving and living descendants of Native American and Indigenous peoples. Their ancestors deaths and loss of land were not the result of being evil, and should not be dishonored with such a myth. Blaming Native Americans for their own genocide and colonization is beyond toxic.

     The above teachings of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints in regards to Lamanites and American Indians are current. To explore these teachings I have included the transcripts below of two conversations I had with Mormon missionaries: (Note: I  will not include the names of the missionaries in the transcript as I want to protect them. I do not hold an 18 or 19 year old responsible for being taught false doctrine with the church’s long held policy of American Indian erasure.)

First Conversation with Missionaries – January 31, 2018

I had wondered for a time if perhaps my experience with racism in the church was uncommon. Perhaps other indigenous people were not taught they were a Lamanite as I was, or that their family who had not joined the church still carried the curse. Was I alone in learning that my indigenous peoples culture, dancing, and celebrations were remnants of evil and turning away from God? Was this experience of mine unique? So I decided to reach out to the missionaries who are official representatives of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints to ensure I was not working under an incorrect understanding. Below is a quote from the first conversation to highlight the offensive teaching that Native Americans had no religion before Columbus came.

Missionary said, “The Nephites, who were generally the more righteous people, were killed off at the end of the Book of Mormon because of their wickedness and lack of turning to Jesus Christ. There was another civilization of people called the Lamanites, who more often than not denied Christ and His existence, and they were always at war with the Nephites. The Lamanites became the Native Americans who were in the Americas when Columbus came and settled the land. That’s why there was no religion established in the land when Columbus came, because the Lamanites didn’t believe in Christ.” To see the full conversation click the following link: My talk with Missionaries.

 

Second Conversation with Mormon Missionaries – April 18, 2018

During that first conversation I had not informed the missionaries that I was Native American. I thought, given the chance, that if they were aware of my ethnicity they would have been more sensitive. So once again I approached the missionaries. Below is a portion of that conversation.

Missionary: “The Book of Mormon actually starts in Israel, but the family moved to the American continent… After thousands of years, all were destroyed except the Lamanites, and they are among the ancestors of the American Indians.”

Sarah: “Only the Lamanites were left at the end of the Book of Mormon, and those are the Native Americans?”

Missionary: “Yes.”

Sarah: “Native Americans have no history of Christianity. Why don’t Native Americans have that in their oral histories at the time America was discovered? I am Native American. I can tell you that my ancestors did not come from that part of the world. Surprised me when you said that the Book of Mormon was of my ancestors.”

Missionary: “Didn’t mean to surprise you! But that is really cool that you’re Native American!”

(I picked up my phone while I was talking to them and typed in a quick search.)

Sarah: “If I search the word Lamanites and the Book of Mormon it brings up a page at the top, which when I open it states something about a skin of blackness.”

Missionary: “Yes, the skin color change was just a sign of a curse, not the curse itself.”

Sarah: “So skin was darkened due to a curse?”

Missionary: “A curse was put upon people. The curse was that they were withdrawn from the spirit of God because they were wicked. The others needed a sign to help them know who didn’t have the spirit with them. So their skin was darkened so they could see who was who. Dark skin is not the curse itself.”

Missionary: (Sharing  2nd Nephi 5:21) “And He had caused the cursing to come upon them, yea, even a sore cursing, because of their iniquity. For behold, they had hardened their hearts against him, that they had become like unto a flint; wherefore, as they were white, and exceedingly fair and delightsome, that they might not be enticing unto my people the Lord God did cause a skin of blackness to come upon them. It would appear that this was done to limit wickedness. The skins of the Lamanites were dark that thereby the Lord God might preserve his people, that they might not mix and believe in incorrect traditions. That is from Alma chapter 3. Throughout the scriptures we find warnings of the Lord to not marry unbelievers. The result of doing so was often that the righteous were turned away from the Lord. Some people have mistakenly thought that the dark skin placed upon the Lamanites was the curse. President Joseph Fielding Smith explained that the dark skin was not the curse. He said that the dark skin was placed upon the Lamanites so that they could be distinguished from the Nephites and to keep the two peoples from mixing. The dark skin was the sign of the curse, not the curse itself. The curse was the withdrawal of the Spirit of the Lord. The dark skin of those who join the church is no longer considered a sign of the curse, these converts are delightsome and have the Spirit of the Lord! One great blessing is that the curse is only valid as long as people are wicked. If the repent, the curse of God will no longer follow them. There are many examples of righteous Lamanites who repented and enjoyed the Spirit of the Lord, one of them even became a prophet.”

Sarah: “Skin color existed long before this timeline. This is naive. Are you telling me God put dark skin on all the people of the world when they were bad? Does that mean only white people were never cursed?”

Missionary: “Not all the people of the world, we only know of the Lamanites. We need to recognize that this was one situation, under these circumstances 2000 years ago. It is not saying all black people are wicked or cursed at all.” To read the full blog post of this conversation click the following link: Second Conversation with Mormon Missionaries.

I wondered for a moment if the missionary believed that these last words somehow showed that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Days Saints was not racist. “Not saying all black people are wicked”, just Lamanites were, just my people… Instead the missionary’s words left me surprised and in pain. The entire conversation was extremely painful.

The evidence that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints is continuing to speculate about who the Lamanites are is obvious. It is unnecessary, as the Book of Mormon is fully capable of standing as a spiritual text without appropriating Native American cultures. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints needs to cease speculation of who the Lamanites are, remove the term “American Indians” from the introduction, and begin training/ educating their official representatives about these issues.

By Sarah Newcomb     Published on March 11, 2019

 

Part Two – History of Missionary Work with Native Americans – COMING SOON

Part Three – Stories – COMING SOON

6 thoughts on “The Lamanite Truth Project – Part One

  1. Perhaps you ought to read the book “He Walked The Americas”, written by a non-LDS researcher in Native anthropology named L. Taylor Hansen, then let me know what you think. Its available on line in pdf format.
    BTW, did you ever research the identity of Wovoka, and how he was deliberately confused with the Saviour when He came down to teach the representatives of first-nations people? And did you discover which of Joseph Smith’s prophesies was fulfilled by His appearance among them at that time?

    Like

    1. Thank you for your comment. I know these are not easy issues to process or understand.

      L. Taylor Hansen is not taken seriously in either the non-LDS or the LDS anthropology or historical fields. The methods used to write the book does not meet any of the standards required, and her stories are not substantiated. It is not a trustable source.

      I think it is important to add that L. Taylor Hansen was not an anthropologist, nor a researcher in the professional field of anthropology.

      As far as Wovoka I am curious about you thoughts around this. Have you read much about his history and the colonization of his people? Have you read any academic papers around it? I would be more than happy to forward some to you.

      I must say this though. Using the events that proceeded the Battle of Wounded Knee to further belief in Joseph Smith is promoting a false narrative. It is not respectful in any way to the surviving Sioux people.

      Like

    2. Anonymous

      Each Native American tribe has its own creation story. I don’t believe any of them would say that their ancestors came from the Middle East. The Siberian theory of migration story is bad enough and insulting enough for the native people, it’s hard for me to buy this Book of Mormon story about Lehi and all the Nephites and Lamanites myth. Why don’t the “Anglo” LSA people call themselves “Nephites” in the present-day church? Would they proud of that label?
      It angers me that the LDS church has been allowed to teach this myth and has taken advantage of our innocent people in brainwashing them with this nonsense!
      It definitely has to stop!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. So much this! Not just that the church has spread a false narrative that seriously needs to stop – but that each Native American tribe has their own history, beliefs, and origins. Thank you.

        Like

  2. Sarah,

    I just came across Mormon Stories and watched your interview. I was really moved. Thank you for doing it.

    I’m an ex-Jack Mormon from Utah also living in Texas (San Antonio). I can envision the subtle and not-so-subtle racism that you experienced. My high school gf was Latina and we felt the weirdness from my TBM grandparents and others. It’s just dumb and unnecessary and pathetic.

    I recently read the CES letter and it blew me away. I had to call my 68-y/o mom in Utah to see if the entire religion was crumbling. She laughed and said that there is no broad reaction to anything. How can this be ignored, I thought? Then I remembered what it was like to be LDS, and it all made sense again.

    The LDS church’s day of reckoning will come. The younger generations won’t be as ignorant as our generation (I’m 41). They will demand the truth and it will crumble because it’s built on a foundation of lies that largely persist to this day.

    Anyway, I just wanted to let you know that your inner and outer beauty are radiant. I wish you peace and healing and happiness. Truly.

    Best wishes to you and your family.

    Sincerely,

    Chad

    Like

    1. Hi Chad,

      I had a similar reaction as I learned how much coverup and white washing there was. I didn’t discover the CES letter for a long time, wouldn’t read anything that wasn’t on the churches websites. Would have saved me so much time though! The Lamanite narrative didn’t hit me until after I decided to leave, was a shock.

      Thank you for sharing about your girlfriend. I always appreciate hearing about it from the non-Indigenous perspective. It needs to be heard.

      I agree it will continue to crumble, or at least really change. When I was still trying to stay in I found it impossible to teach from the lesson manuals. Could not lie to children.

      Thank you so much for your kind words. And yes, there has been tons of healing. Life is good. 😉

      Best regards,
      Sarah

      Like

Leave a Reply to Newcomb Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s